FastOne
Legend
Loyaler
:rofl:
LuckyChippy
Cardschat Elite
Silver Level
GOAT gets his 3rd Balon D'Or
Votes are always worth a few lols, personal faves here are the Venezuelan and Burundi coaches choices
http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/classic/awards/01/56/60/53/awards_men_player_countries.pdf
Sell Pique for a pittance and he turns into a world class defender who picks up points in the Balon D'Or. A defender. Sigh.
The reason there can be no retroactive punishment for Johnson is because the referee saw it and deemed it not a foul, only an incident the referee didn't see or a red card can be appealed. Kompany's wasn't overturned because by the letter of the law and the referee's interpretation it was a red card, there's no way it was ever going to get overturned.
Fwiw I don't think either was a red card but both tackles were slightly different and comparing the two is pointless. A 2 footed tackle has never equalled a red and the FA have never said it is.
Last edited:
B
BlueNowhere
Legend
Silver Level
Which law from 'the letter of the law' did Kompany break? I've looked aat the FA's rule and I have yet to see one that was broken by Kompanys tackle. How do you know the referee saw it? I haven't seen anything that suggests the referee saw the two footed lunge, which at the very least it was a foul. Surely if one referee sends off Kompany and one doesn't give a foul to Johnson one referee needs to be held accountable and neither has.
LuckyChippy
Cardschat Elite
Silver Level
It was deemed a reckless tackle. I agree it shouldn't have been a red but it was never going to be overturned. He left the ground with both feet in a scissor motion and forced a player to jump over him. These factors can be considered reckless and they will back the referee. In a somewhat twisted way I don't think it should have been a red but believe the decision should stand, as it did.
The second part is nonsense, of course the referee saw the tackle because he was watching the game, he just decided it wasn't a foul, something I agree with.
Like I said before, there is no mechanism to 'hold accountable' the referee. The only things that can even be looked at retroactively are things the referee didn't see and didn't put in his report and red cards. Kompany's was appealed and upheld for the reasons I stated and Johnson's was dealt with by the referee.
At the end of the day it's all an interpretation by the referee using clearly stated rules and somewhat ambiguous guidance.
B
BlueNowhere
Legend
Silver Level
It was never a reckless challenge that endangered anyone though. He came in with one foot (the scissor motion didn't happen till after Nani had gone past and he was bringing the ball under control) and cleanly won the ball. Giggs challenge on Aguero was actually much worse, from behind with an actual scissor motion. Johnsons is cloer to a red card as he comes in with feet together diving in with his whole weight behind the challenge. If Nani, the biggest woman in football, didn't think Kompanys was a bad challenge then I don't see how the ref can have given a red card. It was a referee error from a referee who has been an absolute disgrace recently, Spurs-Stoke and Chelsea-QPR being two matches where he showed he is not competant enough to manage in the premier league. How he got awarded a huge FA cup game is beyond me. He gave a wrongful red card to Kompany, should have certainly booked Giggs at least, United should have had another penalty, City should have had a penalty. One of the worst referring performances I have seen in a long time, it was almost like he was trying to rival Ovrebo in displays of ineptitude.
Yes he saw the tackle, I doubt he saw the nature of the tackle as it was a definite foul and he didn't give it
The method to hold accountable referees would be to demote them, not reward them with even bigger games. Also they should come out and admit when they get major decisions wrong. The card would have been rescinded if Foy could have at least admitted to his mistake, however he compunded it by maintaining it was a red card.
Yes he saw the tackle, I doubt he saw the nature of the tackle as it was a definite foul and he didn't give it
The method to hold accountable referees would be to demote them, not reward them with even bigger games. Also they should come out and admit when they get major decisions wrong. The card would have been rescinded if Foy could have at least admitted to his mistake, however he compunded it by maintaining it was a red card.
Dorkus Malorkus
HELLO INTERNET
Silver Level
Gesshoo
RIP Buck.
Silver Level
Delighted we won, but I thought ManU had the better of it until the last 15-20 minutes when the Liverpool subs had a big impact. Carragher in midfield didn't work out, Stevie didn't have his best ever game and Henderson was largely anonymous.
I excuse all of that after a tough game on Wednesday. I think we are still struggling to know our best line-up. Defence looks OK, and we have a potentially great midfield with any 4 or 5 from Gerrard, Lucas, Kuyt, Henderson, Downing, Maxi, Adam and maybe Spearing....up front, we need Carroll to find his game and we need Suarez back to support Bellamy who is playing great right now.
Still need more cover in all 3 areas....one really great player in each makes us contenders next year. A great defender, great midfielder and a truly great goalscorer, like a Hunt, Rush, Aldridge, Fowler, Owen...this is about the first time in 40 years we haven't had one.
I excuse all of that after a tough game on Wednesday. I think we are still struggling to know our best line-up. Defence looks OK, and we have a potentially great midfield with any 4 or 5 from Gerrard, Lucas, Kuyt, Henderson, Downing, Maxi, Adam and maybe Spearing....up front, we need Carroll to find his game and we need Suarez back to support Bellamy who is playing great right now.
Still need more cover in all 3 areas....one really great player in each makes us contenders next year. A great defender, great midfielder and a truly great goalscorer, like a Hunt, Rush, Aldridge, Fowler, Owen...this is about the first time in 40 years we haven't had one.
beardyian
Scary Clown
Silver Level
rotty
I triple dog dare ya
Loyaler
Ian, can you score me some home match tickets so i can see you play?
Worak
Legend
Bronze Level
Congratulations to Newcastle United for adding Cissé to their team.
He showed excellent performance during his stay in Freiburg i.B. in the German Bundesliga scoring 2nd most goals last season - and that with a rather mediocre team.
22 goals last season - he should be able to score at least another 10 in this season following his initial goal in the first game he played for Newcastle.
He showed excellent performance during his stay in Freiburg i.B. in the German Bundesliga scoring 2nd most goals last season - and that with a rather mediocre team.
22 goals last season - he should be able to score at least another 10 in this season following his initial goal in the first game he played for Newcastle.