Correct to remove Russia from international sport?

Rob Hobson

Rob Hobson

Legend
Loyaler
Joined
Feb 2, 2012
Total posts
4,613
Awards
2
BR
Chips
605
What do you think, is it fair to want to deprive Russian sports of the right to play at the World Cup and Russian clubs threaten to forget about European competition forever?

I think that sports should not be intertwined with politics, why should we suffer innocent citizens. why they want to deprive us of these emotions, I remember the doping scandal is all nonsense, even the last case with Kamila Valieva is simply awful.
I agree with you!
 
Nokaut men 1997

Nokaut men 1997

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Total posts
134
Awards
1
BA
Chips
214
How is it possible that Russian tennis players play ATP tournaments, win big cash prizes, and Russia and Putin profit by collecting large amounts of taxes on the prizes of Russian tennis players.
What are the leading people of ATP thinking about?
 
ScooperNova

ScooperNova

Hair in a Biscuit
Loyaler
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Total posts
2,495
Awards
3
US
Chips
528
I was super tolerant to russians all that time since I joined forum in 2016. Not anymore. I have all reasons and rights to disrespect them and people who protects them.

Uncountable numbers of innocent people got killed or injured by Russians and Belarussians already and it will be worse every day.

My mom got ill because of stress and can't sleep because of air raid sirens.

You and everybody else who defends war criminals and terrorists and accuse peaceful free people must be banned and judged.

Recent data shows 71% of Russian people support Putin's actions so they are criminals too and must respond too.
Almost all companies of the free world already implemented sanctions, suspended or frozen accounts or left Russian market mostly because they don't want huge reputational losses.
I'm looking for the part where I (checks notes) "defended terrorists and criminals" but I can't seem to find it. Where are you getting your "recent data"? The only other person I saw make a claim like this was getting data from Russian propaganda sources because it fit the point they thought they were proving and it was quite hilarious. Perhaps Russia is allowing foreign third parties to poll their citizens concerning their thoughts on the war and I am unaware of it.
 
ScooperNova

ScooperNova

Hair in a Biscuit
Loyaler
Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Total posts
2,495
Awards
3
US
Chips
528
How is it possible that Russian tennis players play ATP tournaments, win big cash prizes, and Russia and Putin profit by collecting large amounts of taxes on the prizes of Russian tennis players.
What are the leading people of ATP thinking about?
It's actually pennies compared to the billions of dollars in oil EU countries have bought from Russia since the war has started. But hey, those tennis prize pennies and big mac taxes were really adding up.
 
M

Marcos1315

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Total posts
140
Chips
1
About previous invasion to Iraq. You can agree with, you can consider it a big mistake and crime. But you should understand that Russia is doing much worse crime.
- I dont see any request to Iraq to cease part of its territory to US
- Iraq was apparently attacking other states and used chemical weapon againts its own citizes
- and of course you could protest agains Iraq war in US and noone would beat you

And other arguments.
I was always against invasion to Iraq, mostly because I believe such invasion can never bring much good to country, even if it removes evil dictator.
But what Russia is doing to Ukraine since 2014 is much much worse.


But sanctions, bans, etc. they are because of the war. If it were due to oppression, many countries (including Russia) would have faced these things before.

As for chemical weapons, the US made use of them in Vietnam, for example.


To be clear: I am totally against the invasion and I think Putin is a dictator. I strongly disagree with Ukraine (for example, the president of Ukraine could have prevented this war, and one of his responsibilities is to protect his people. When he doesn't stop this war and make people die, I think it's his responsibility. I can't agree with this glamor that he's having to defend his country this way. How can that be a good defense if a lot of people are dying and leaving and the structure of the country is falling apart?), but I don't think Russia is right.

The point is that it is "cool" to attack Russia in any way possible. For example, a restaurant here in brazil stopped cooking Russian food. People are "playing for the fans" (this is an expression we use to describe a player who is doing something unnecessary, like sliding to save a ball that is out of bounds in football/soccer, just for the fans to celebrate his 'effort') .

I don't disagree with many things done, I just think it's biased. It should have been done with other countries as well.
 
M

Marcos1315

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Total posts
140
Chips
1
I respect people with critical thinking and it is very sad that there are very few such people.
«Putin has lied about the Ukraine 'Nazi' government, it simply isn't true. Zelensky is Jewish, his grandparents fought against the previous Hitler.»
Very convincing. The question immediately arises.
Is there a fascist movement in Ukraine?
The question is answered by the documentary film by Polish journalists " Rafal Stanczyk and Yaroslav Germozyak "Fascists in the Trenches" 2015."
Then a counter question arises.
Why the government of Ukraine does not suppress the fascist movement, on the contrary, does it encourage him?
Isn't it a puzzle?
And now about the removal of Russian athletes from all international competitions.
The International Olympic Committee (IOC) issued a statement condemning Russia's violation of the Olympic Truce, which is in effect during the Olympic and Paralympic Games.
And he recommended to remove all Russian athletes from international competitions.
And immediately questions. Why do Ukrainian athletes take part in the Olympics, whose government kills its own citizens in the Donbass? Did the Ukrainian state observe the Olympic Truce?
And who was to blame?
Review what your leaders said during the Olympics? What did they respond to the requests of the Russian side to stop the intensified shelling of Donbass by the military of Ukraine?
It seems like the world has gone crazy.



I hate that "oh, but he's Jewish".
There is a documentary on Netflix about Otto Skorzeny (Nazi, SS, rescued Mussolini).

He always believed in Nazi principles, and the Mossad used him to defend Israel.
At first it seems crazy to think that this could happen, but it does.

US and Soviet Union were allied in WWII.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otto_Skorzeny#Alleged_recruitment_by_Mossad
https://forward.com/news/336943/ht/
 
YRAGAGARIN

YRAGAGARIN

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
Jan 30, 2022
Total posts
97
Chips
0
I don't think sports and politics should be mixed.
 
Tredford

Tredford

Enthusiast
Silver Level
Joined
Feb 21, 2022
Total posts
55
Chips
0
Russia has blocked or cause to be terminated a lot of Ukrainian "sporting" activities.
Until the Ukraines can play online poker again, Russian players should be banned.
 
elchonga

elchonga

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Jul 22, 2020
Total posts
574
Awards
2
AR
Chips
114
It has nothing to do one thing with the other
 
peaceofcoke

peaceofcoke

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Jun 29, 2019
Total posts
720
Awards
3
Chips
12
Well, there is no legal basis for FIFA or IOC to ban Russia and Belarus from international sports. In their charter, both organizations proclaim to be unpolitical, the said charter is signed by all members of not only both organizations but also members of FIBA, FIVB, etc.
Russia and Belarus will point directly to that charter, arguing that they have no influence over the politics of their countries, and politicians do not interfere in their countries' sporting matters, as imposed by the very same charter of these organizations.
They will also argue that countries like Kuwait, Eritrea, Malaysia were suspended because of politicians' influence on FA in their countries.
The TAS/CAS will find no legal ground for suspending Russia and Russian clubs by FIFA and UEFA because the Russian FA abides by the FIFA charter, whilst FIFA ignores it completely for P.R stunts.
FIFA might argue about human rights and how Russia violates H.R. in Ukraine, Russians will backfire by stating Guantanamo, Uighurs, Gilet Jaune, Inuit people, U.A.E, and Saudi Arabia in Yemen, Armenia/Azerbaijan conflict, Israeli/Palestinian conflict, etc. but more importantly how Paedophilia is so prevalent in many an FA across the globe, especially in Gabon, Haiti, france, Mongolia, etc. and how FIFA keeps ignoring them or tries to make these cases disappear. Not only that, but also match-fixing in Eastern Europe, South America, Africa, Asia and how recently FIFA is unable to protect its employees, e.g. in Cyprus or mexico where Mafia and Cartels control, extort, batter, and assault, etc.
Not only that but also human trafficking and children traficking from African countries into South East Asia, especially to Thailand to play football there.
FIFA has just shot itself in the foot, banning Russia, the decision will be turned in favor of Russia and Russian clubs, and no wonder if we see Zenit v RB in the next week
If you want to argue about IOC suspending Russian athletes, well that was a case of doping, which is tightly related to sports
 
Last edited:
peaceofcoke

peaceofcoke

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Jun 29, 2019
Total posts
720
Awards
3
Chips
12
Perhaps - but:

* Putin did it to a peaceful people for no good reason whilst lying to the international community, the Ukrainians and even his own people (and continues to do so);
* Putin punishes his own people if they even dare to try to tell the truth of what is really going on;
*Putin is killing innocent civilians including children simply because they don't want to be so called 'rescued';
* and, none of the countries you mention have threated the world with nuclear bombs
-I know of many countries around the world, peaceful countries until France, the USA, intervened and bombed them. It is wrong on both sides, Russians are wrong, Americans and Europeans too.
-Racism, xenophobia, and punishing politicians is too prevalent not only in Russia but all over the world, if you don't hear about it in mainstream media, it doesn't mean it isn't there. When you are in America, just say I am communist, not even that, just say I am socialist. As when you are in France, wear a yellow vest, or try to book a ticket to see some comedians, or go to Soral's political rally, you can't. The icing on the cake, if you are a holocaust denier you will go to prison, and there are many more subjects that you cannot talk about, freedom of speech is tightly tied with what the media feeds you.

-I know of a country that has actually used Nukes, what about you?
 
yetbam

yetbam

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Jun 16, 2011
Total posts
178
Awards
1
MX
Chips
143
severe penalties





from my point of view it seems to me that not only Russia should be penalized with the exclusion of its athletes from sports, let us remember that for a conflict to exist there must always be two parties and from that context it seems to me that the same decisions are not being made With Ukraine, we must remember that they are also partly to blame and that should be taken into consideration when applying sanctions as well as for the countries that have been involved as instigators of the conflict.



:(:confused:
 
S

skaterick

Legend
Loyaler
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Total posts
1,973
Awards
10
US
Chips
292
russian professional beach volleyball teams

have been removed from the circuit . the tennis tour should follow suit !
 
fullclock

fullclock

Legend
Bronze Level
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Total posts
1,023
Awards
4
Chips
84
I think that the exclusion of Russia in almost all sports is correct. This must be paid for so much pain that is causing innocents and children.
 
S

skaterick

Legend
Loyaler
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Total posts
1,973
Awards
10
US
Chips
292
hurray for the British !

no Russians at Wimbledon . the Brits seem to have more fortitude than we do here in the USA .
 
Kinalha

Kinalha

Legend
Platinum Level
Joined
May 2, 2020
Total posts
1,480
Awards
2
BR
Chips
269
all decisions with a war in the middle are confuses..
 
hubcio96

hubcio96

Rock Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Oct 31, 2019
Total posts
253
Awards
1
Chips
23
Why do people have to pay for their government action? I don't think banning Russian athletes is right, but I do understand the need for pressure to change the government. The only change of regime in Russia happened from internal revolutions. I don't think there is foreign country or influence that was successful in abolishing and changing Russian Government. It can only be done within, so putting pressure on the Country as a whole might do the trick.
 
emejota23

emejota23

Rock Star
Silver Level
Joined
Mar 24, 2022
Total posts
135
Chips
0
Why do people have to pay for their government action? I don't think banning Russian athletes is right, but I do understand the need for pressure to change the government. The only change of regime in Russia happened from internal revolutions. I don't think there is foreign country or influence that was successful in abolishing and changing Russian Government. It can only be done within, so putting pressure on the Country as a whole might do the trick.


brother you are absolutely right, I really don't understand why fifa declines russia in the world cup, and also in the olympic games, and pokerstars and other poker platforms, also russian players, they don't have to pay righteous for sinners. :cool:
 
S

Spheremaster

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Mar 27, 2021
Total posts
617
Awards
1
Chips
87
Russian and Belarusian players will not be allowed to compete at Wimbledon this year because of the invasion of Ukraine.
It's official.
 
Risto234

Risto234

põrandaalune pokkerimängija
Loyaler
Joined
Mar 26, 2018
Total posts
17,280
Awards
4
EE
Chips
591
Why do people have to pay for their government action? I don't think banning Russian athletes is right, but I do understand the need for pressure to change the government. The only change of regime in Russia happened from internal revolutions. I don't think there is foreign country or influence that was successful in abolishing and changing Russian Government. It can only be done within, so putting pressure on the Country as a whole might do the trick.


Until ukrainian athles are unable to compete in whatever sporting event all these sanctions in sports world for russians are more than justified ...
 
elchonga

elchonga

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Jul 22, 2020
Total posts
574
Awards
2
AR
Chips
114
a shame what they do by mixing things and a shame also the little solidarity of the other athletes to the Russian athletes
 
B

blata8ruga

Visionary
Bronze Level
Joined
Nov 8, 2018
Total posts
877
Awards
2
Chips
46
I think it is fair, any pressure you can put on Russia is good pressure.
 
Ragonesi

Ragonesi

Rock Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Jan 3, 2022
Total posts
156
Awards
1
Chips
0
Not fair at all, not all russians support the lunatic running the country, actually there are more people against then pro, its a matter of time for Putin to fall...
 
hubcio96

hubcio96

Rock Star
Bronze Level
Joined
Oct 31, 2019
Total posts
253
Awards
1
Chips
23
Until ukrainian athles are unable to compete in whatever sporting event all these sanctions in sports world for russians are more than justified ...


That is actually one of the simplest, cleanest, and "make sense" justification I've heard. Well done
 
Top