What do you guys think of GSP comeback. And what do uyou think drove his success in coming back when comparing to the failure of Silva, Lesnar etc when trying to do the same?
Yeah what Hillbilly said - he was allowed to cherry-pick a matchup that he liked, even though it was in a weight class he'd never fought at before.
As for comparing it to the comebacks of Silva and Lesnar... I think in comparing it to Silva, GSP is still a lot younger. Silva was a few weeks shy of turning
40 when he fought Bisping. He was fighting a younger guy, who was also a problematic style matchup for him and still arguably at the tail end of his prime. And Silva
still almost won that fight. I'm assuming that's the "failure" combeback fight we're talking about with him BTW, since he technically won the comeback fight against Diaz after the broken leg (drug test failure aside).
GSP, on the other hand, is "only" 36. He was the younger man in his matchup with Bisping. Also Bisping was pretty clearly in decline at that stage, given his previous fight was more than a year before and that was a super-shaky performance against old man Dan Henderson.
As for Lesnar, I don't really know how to rate his "comeback", or if it really even was one. It seemed pretty clear to me he was just there to get paid, and it's possible he didn't even care about whether he won or lost. On that note though, it was put together at short notice, in a matchup that while still dangerous gave him a pretty clear path to victory (I love love
love Mark Hunt, but a grappler he is not)... and he won. He obviously failed his drug test but again, I've got to wonder whether he even cares about that given he was going straight back to his WWE payday.
Short version: GSP succeeded where Silva didn't because he's much younger and had a better matchup.