I wish you guys gave us the choice between Brian and someone else. Phil is tough even to talk about. What a character !
Anyway, Brian is a terrific player no doubt, but despite the number of his huge cashes, I'm inclined to call him a "Rising Star" (Sorry CC, I had to steel that from you in this contest

). And even though the "Brat" could be a real brat sometimes, there's History that could not be erased or forgotten, not to mention the stats that speak for themselves in term of prestigious Bracelets and big events Finale Tables of different variants of poker.
I think Brian will definitely catch up in the near future, but for now, I have to go with Phil (I don't even like him that much


).