Best Quarterbacks in the NFL

[PasoTex]

Who are the five best quarterbacks in the NFL? Here are my picks.

1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Philip Rivers
5. Tony Romo

What do you guys think?

 

[MrPokerVerse]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Brett Farve
4. Tom Brady
5. Ben Roethlisberger

All Superbowl proven winners.

On the rise:

Aaron Rodgers
Matt Schaub
Philip Rivers
Matt Ryan
Mark Sanchez

 

[davem86]

Who are the five best quarterbacks in the NFL? Here are my picks.

1. Peyton Manning--YES
2. Tom Brady--SPYGATE?--NOW SUCKS!
3. Drew Brees--Fluke
4. Philip Rivers--WHO
5. Tony Romo--lmfao

What do you guys think?

Random Order

Favre--Retire already (Ima Packer Fan)
Brees--**Cough** FLUKE(great for NO to win tho)
Manning--simply amazing
Rodgers--Plz sum1 block
Vick--wherever he goes he will do great!

 

[t1riel]

Random Order

Favre--*Choke*
Brees--Won Super Bowl with smart decisions unlike....
Manning--*Choke*
Rodgers--Seriously?
Vick--if he can't run, he's toast.

FYP

 

[Marginal]

Warren Beatty is number 1 in my book. No one was ever as good/ will ever be as good.

 

[CasperJames]

Brees a fluke? Uh, he was putting up monster numbers before last season. He's no fluke.

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Brady, but I'm iffy on this one after last season.
4. Rogers
5. Rivers

I left Favre off since he might finally be retired.

 

[t1riel]

Brees a fluke? Uh, he was putting up monster numbers before last season. He's no fluke.

1. Manning
2. Brees
3. Brady, but I'm iffy on this one after last season.
4. Rogers
5. Rivers

I left Favre off since he might finally be retired.

Coming off of ACL surgery is not an easy thing to come back from. He still has the best postseason record out of all the active quarterbacks out there right now.

 

[CasperJames]

Coming off of ACL surgery is not an easy thing to come back from. He still has the best postseason record out of all the active quarterbacks out there right now.

Yep, that's why I still list him as 3rd. He very well could jump to 2nd or even 1st next season, but it would be hard for me to rank him over Peyton.

 

[dead spade]

payton mannig
drew breez
bret farve
ben rothibuerger
mark sanchez

and fuuuuuuuck tom brady it was a fumble WTF IS A TUCK what a fluke that was:thrasher:

 

[dead spade]

i want to add bruce gradkaski as a long shot i think with a full seasson to work he can do somthing really good with the raiders, acctualy he just made the games exciting for me to watch my raiders:thrasher:

 

[davem86]

FYP

HA crazy season this year so cant wait? NE fan im guessing

 

[CasperJames]

i want to add bruce gradkaski as a long shot i think with a full seasson to work he can do somthing really good with the raiders, acctualy he just made the games exciting for me to watch my raiders:thrasher:

 

[PC69]

Brady
Favre
P. Manning
Brees
E. Manning.

 

[t1riel]

payton mannig
drew breez
bret farve
ben rothibuerger
mark sanchez

and fuuuuuuuck tom brady it was a fumble WTF IS A TUCK what a fluke that was:thrasher:

First of all, if you're going to make a list make sure you spell the QBs names correctly. Sanchez? LOL! That's a good one.

Raiders fan? or maybe Jets fan?

 

[jaycism]

I think there are only two quarterbacks in the league that are worth putting up. Peyton Manning and Drew Breeze. There are no others in their category. There are still good quarterbacks in the league with a good cast to help them be a playoff team which good thing but a quarterback to put them on their shoulder and do it is those two quarterbacks I just mentioned.

 

[PC69]

I think there are only two quarterbacks in the league that are worth putting up. Peyton Manning and Drew Breeze. There are no others in their category. There are still good quarterbacks in the league with a good cast to help them be a playoff team which good thing but a quarterback to put them on their shoulder and do it is those two quarterbacks I just mentioned.

Bwahahaha. are u bananas? Brady didnt have that great of a year last year but who in the hell do u think got them all those superbowls..? LOL..

 

[rodpoker]

1. P. Manning 2. Brees 3. Brady 4. Rodgers 5. Rivers

 

[atlantafalcons0]

So now aaron rodgers is better than phillip rivers?

You guys serious???

 

[atlantafalcons0]

I think there are only two quarterbacks in the league that are worth putting up. Peyton Manning and Drew Breeze. There are no others in their category. There are still good quarterbacks in the league with a good cast to help them be a playoff team which good thing but a quarterback to put them on their shoulder and do it is those two quarterbacks I just mentioned.

Yea right dude, I don't know what you're smoking but Tom brady is still better than drew brees.


It goes PEYTON MANNING, and then everyone else.

 

[durrr i win]

:thrasher: ya boy 1.Mark Sanchez


forget the rest

 

[steveestewart]

What about Jake Delhomme?? Glad to see him leave the Panthers

 

[Pokerstudent]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Drew Brees
3. Brett Farve
4. Tom Brady
5. Matt Schaub = Aaron Rodgers

Hard to answer if you are not specific. When you ask who the best quarterback is, what do you mean? Irrespective of their team?

For example, if you took Peyton off of the Colts and put him on the Seahawks, the Seahawks would be respectable. If you did it with Rivers or Brady, they'd still be the Seahawks.....and they'd still suck.

Very easy to say "oh, he's the best! Look at his year"

I love what Farve did this year. Hall of famer, no doubt. But if he didn't have Sidney Rice, would Berrian and the young guy be enough?

Then you have to look at the O-line. How much time does the QB have in the pocket? Although I HATE DEL-HOMIE, his and the Jag's O-line was atrocious this year. The QB can't do anything like that?

All I'm saying is as it is phrased, it is not a simple cut-and-dried question.

 

[Tygran]

currently?

P Manning
D Brees
A Rodgers
P Rivers
T Brady

 

[5TR8 FLUSH]

1. Peyton Manning
2. Bret Favre
3. Drew Brees
4. Phillip Rivers
5. Donovan Mcnabb
6. Tom "brady bunch" Brady - "BIG" Ben Roethlisberger
7. Kurt Warner
8. Tony Romo
9. Carson Palmer
10. Aaron Rodgers
11. Matt Schaub
12. Eli Manning
13. Matt Cassel
14. Mike Vick
15. Matt Ryan - Joe Flacco

 

[Tygran]

Bwahahaha. are u bananas? Brady didnt have that great of a year last year but who in the hell do u think got them all those superbowls..? LOL..

Belicheck

(his video camera helped too...)

plain and simple